Johnson-Melloh Residential
Heating & coolingAll heating & coolingFurnace repairFurnace replacementAC repairAC replacementCooling serviceHeat pumpsTune-ups and maintenance
PlumbingAll plumbingWater heaters and tanklessWater treatmentSump pumpsWater line repair and replacementFixture replacement
Drains & sewerAll drains & sewerClogged and backed-up drainsCamera inspectionsSewer line serviceSewage ejector pumpsHydro jetting
FinancingPricingAbout us
Service areaAll of our service areaMarion CountyHamilton CountyBoone CountyHendricks CountyHancock CountyJohnson CountyMorgan CountyMadison CountyShelby County
Homeowner ResourcesCustomer portalMake a payment
  1. Home
  2. Homeowner Resources
  3. Tank or tankless water heater

Guide

Tank or Tankless Water Heater: What to Know Before You Choose

When a water heater fails, you have a decision to make quickly. Here is how the two types differ, and what to ask before you switch.

How Each One Works

A tank water heater keeps a supply of water hot and ready. When you use more than the tank holds, you wait for it to recover. A tankless water heater heats water as it flows through, so it does not run out the same way, but it is sized to how many showers, faucets and appliances run at the same time.

Both run on gas or electricity, and both need proper venting, connections and setup to work safely.

What to Ask Before You Switch

How many people are in the house, and how much hot water do you use at once? Does your current gas line, venting and electrical service support a tankless unit, or would they need changes? How long do you plan to stay in the home?

We will answer those for your home specifically and give you the installed price of each option. Sometimes replacing tank for tank is the sensible choice; sometimes tankless makes more sense.

Keeping Either One Running

Sediment is the enemy of tank water heaters. Most manufacturers recommend flushing the tank once a year. The DOE Building America Solution Center explains how sediment reduces a heater's ability to heat water.

Tankless units need periodic maintenance too, especially where water is hard. A water softener can reduce scale on both types.

Questions Homeowners Ask Us

Still have a question? Call dispatch.

(317) 891-5671

Monday to Friday, 7:30 AM to 4 PM

Is a tankless water heater worth it?

It depends on your household's hot water use, what your home needs to support one, and how long you plan to stay. We will price both options for your home.

How often should I flush my water heater?

Most manufacturers recommend once a year.

Homes with lit windows at dusk

Tell Us What Is Going on at Home

Call (317) 891-5671 or schedule online. Dispatch will confirm a time, and a union certified technician will tell you what we found, what it needs and what it costs.

Call (317) 891-5671Schedule