Johnson-Melloh Residential
Heating & coolingAll heating & coolingFurnace repairFurnace replacementAC repairAC replacementCooling serviceHeat pumpsTune-ups and maintenance
PlumbingAll plumbingWater heaters and tanklessWater treatmentSump pumpsWater line repair and replacementFixture replacement
Drains & sewerAll drains & sewerClogged and backed-up drainsCamera inspectionsSewer line serviceSewage ejector pumpsHydro jetting
FinancingPricingAbout us
Service areaAll of our service areaMarion CountyHamilton CountyBoone CountyHendricks CountyHancock CountyJohnson CountyMorgan CountyMadison CountyShelby County
Homeowner ResourcesCustomer portalMake a payment
  1. Home
  2. Homeowner Resources
  3. Should you repair or replace your furnace or AC?

Guide

Should You Repair or Replace Your Furnace or AC?

Can this be repaired, or does it need to be replaced? It is the question we hear most. Here is how we answer it, and how you can think it through.

We Do Not Automatically Push Replacement

When we answer this question, we explain what we found, the condition of the equipment, and the practical repair and replacement options available. Then we give you the price of each. The decision is yours.

A repair is often the right call. A new system is a major investment, and replacing equipment that still has good years left does not help anyone.

The Questions That Decide It

How old is it? Central air conditioners typically last twelve to fifteen years with maintenance. A furnace past fifteen years is worth evaluating, especially if repairs are adding up.

How much is the repair compared with replacement? A small repair on a sound system is usually worth it. A large repair on an older system deserves a side-by-side comparison.

Safety and Efficiency

Is it safe? A cracked heat exchanger can allow carbon monoxide into the house, and that changes the conversation. Combustion and carbon monoxide testing is part of our heating tune-up.

What does it cost to run? If your furnace is more than fifteen years old, a new unit could cut annual heating gas use by up to 20 percent, depending on the efficiency of the one you have. Citizens Energy Group, the Indianapolis gas utility, says upgrading a furnace that is more than twelve years old will save energy and may save money, and recommends regular professional maintenance either way.

If You Decide to Replace

A replacement starts with an evaluation and a quote: sizing, model choices, and your budget. Nothing is scheduled until you approve it.

Financing is available for qualifying projects, subject to credit approval. See financing options, or read about furnace replacement and AC replacement.

Questions Homeowners Ask Us

Still have a question? Call dispatch.

(317) 891-5671

Monday to Friday, 7:30 AM to 4 PM

What is the $5,000 rule for HVAC?

It is a rule of thumb some people use: multiply the age of the unit by the repair cost, and consider replacing if the result is over 5,000. It is a starting point, not an answer; condition and safety matter more.

Will you tell me if I should keep my old system?

Yes. If a repair makes more sense than a new system, we say so.

Homes with lit windows at dusk

Tell Us What Is Going on at Home

Call (317) 891-5671 or schedule online. Dispatch will confirm a time, and a union certified technician will tell you what we found, what it needs and what it costs.

Call (317) 891-5671Schedule